← Pitch to Handoff · Worked example (anonymised). File names in the text refer to the evidence files in the download.

Worked example 1 - site-audit

Target: Family Plumbing Co., Northtown CA - https://plumber-a.example/ (public small-business site) Run: 2026-11-19. Facts collected with tools/site_facts.py --weight (saved in evidence/plumber-a.facts.json) plus a 390 px-wide headless Chrome render and its console log (screenshots omitted from the anonymised pack). Input given to the skill: URL; "local plumber, Northtown/Eastbury, goal = phone calls and estimate requests"; site_facts JSON. Anonymised: the business name, URLs, people, phone numbers and addresses are replaced with neutral placeholders; the findings come from a real public small-business site checked on 2026-11-19. Public pages only, no logins. Re-check before quoting anything - sites change.


Site audit: Family Plumbing Co. - https://plumber-a.example/

Checked: 2026-11-19, homepage only (single-page site; /robots.txt and /sitemap.xml return 404). Mobile render: yes (390 px).

Verdict

The site is a one-page, template-based site that reads clearly and sounds like real people, but a visitor on a phone cannot tap the phone number, the page never shows a licence, insurance or opening hours, and five resources are blocked by the browser. The company's strongest asset (a long, personal story and sensible service list) is undermined by trust gaps that matter for a trade where strangers let you into their home. Fix the phone number and the trust block first; both are under an hour of work.

Top 3 fixes

  1. Make the phone number tappable (and visible in the header on mobile) - Severity: High | Effort: S | Owner: freelancer Evidence: the header contains <p><strong>Call (555) 010-0100</strong></p> and the page has 0 tel: links [seen in HTML; contact_paths.tel_links = []]. The only link-type contact on the page is mailto:owner@plumber-a.example. Why it costs money: someone with a leaking pipe on a phone has to memorise or copy a number instead of tapping it; many will tap the next plumber in the search results. Fix: wrap the number in <a href="tel:+15550100100">, repeat it as a button in the first screen and in the Contact section, and add an obvious "Request a free estimate" mailto/form as the second route.

  2. Add a trust block: licence number, insurance, service hours - Severity: High | Effort: S (needs owner input) | Owner: owner supplies, freelancer places Evidence: the words licence/licensed and insured/insurance appear nowhere on the page, nor do opening hours (trust_words_found: licence false, insurance false). The page does say "Give us a call anytime to set up a free estimate". Why it costs money: a homeowner choosing someone to open their walls looks for proof they are legitimate; California contractors generally have to show their state licence number in advertising - confirm the exact rule with the CSLB before telling the client it is required. Even where it is optional, it is the first trust signal visitors look for. Fix: add one line under the intro: "CA Contractor's License #[ASK OWNER] - Bonded and insured [ASK OWNER to confirm]" and the real hours ("Mon-Fri ..., emergency calls ...").

  3. Resolve the date conflict and refresh the footer - Severity: Medium-High | Effort: S | Owner: owner confirms Evidence: the page says "Serving the Bayside Area since 1992" and also "In 2009 [Owner] started Family Plumbing Co."; footer reads "© 2014 Family Plumbing Co., All rights reserved". Why it costs money: two different start dates read as carelessness or exaggeration, and a 2014 footer in 2026 reads as "is this business still operating?" Fix: ask the owner what 1992 refers to (family history? [Owner]'s career start?) and phrase it precisely, e.g. "Family-run, serving the Bayside Area since 2009" or "[Owner]'s family has plumbed in Northtown since 1992" - whichever is true. Update to a dynamic year.

All findings

# Area Finding Evidence Severity Effort
1 B Contact Phone not tappable "Call (555) 010-0100" is plain text; tel_links: [] High S
2 C Trust No licence, insurance or hours shown trust-word scan: licence false, insurance false High S
3 C Trust Contradictory start dates + stale footer "since 1992" vs "In 2009 [Owner] started"; "© 2014" Med-High S
4 E Technical 3 scripts and 2 font stylesheets requested over http:// from an https:// page; Chrome blocks them Console: "Mixed Content: ... requested an insecure script 'http://code.jquery.com/jquery-1.10.2.min.js'. This request has been blocked" (also jquery.validate, jquery.form.js, Google Fonts Raleway and Open Sans) Medium S
5 E Technical <title> is fine but meta description is empty; H1 is only a logo image with alt "Plumber A" <meta name="description" content="">; <h1><img ... alt="Plumber A"></h1> Medium S
6 D Speed 3 of 4 images are PNG photos of 143-234 KB, no width/height set; total page about 0.7 MB (fine) fire_pit.png 234,263 B; sink.png 198,774 B; owners.png 143,248 B Low-Med S
7 C Trust Only 2 testimonials, first name + initial; link to Yelp but no star rating or count shown on the page text: "Reviewer 1, Northtown", "Reviewer 2, Bigcity"; "View us on Yelp!" Medium S
8 A Clarity The first screen opens with the logo and two paragraphs; no clear action button 390 px render: header text, logo, paragraphs; no button above the fold Medium S
9 B Contact No form: the only written channel is a mailto: link forms: 0; mailto:owner@plumber-a.example Medium M
10 F Local Bayside Area towns named once; no service-area detail beyond "Northtown, Eastbury, and the greater Bayside Area" intro paragraph Low-Med M
11 E Technical Page depends on jQuery 1.10.2 (released 2013) and a template-era script stack; likely unmaintained [inferred] script jquery-1.10.2.min.js; an IE-only conditional comment still points at html5shim.googlecode.com (Google Code shut down in 2016) Low M

What already works

  • "We take the time to educate our customers about their options for saving money, conserving water, and avoiding future plumbing problems." - a specific, human differentiator; keep it prominent.
  • "Experience with preservation of systems as old as 1920, often found in older Northtown buildings" - local, credible expertise that generic competitors can't claim.
  • A real owner story with names ("[Owner A] and his wife [Office Manager]") and two long, specific testimonials - this is rarer than it should be and should be kept and expanded.
  • Services are listed with concrete items (CSST gas piping, earthquake valves, tankless heaters, graywater) - useful for visitors and for search.

Not checked

  • Whether the contact route works (no form to test; email delivery unknown).
  • Google Business Profile, reviews on Google/Yelp, and how the site appears in search (no access to rank data).
  • Real-device speed (no Lighthouse run; sizes are raw bytes).
  • Whether the blocked scripts break any visible feature: they drive the smooth-scroll nav and lightbox (jquery.nav, prettyPhoto); the content itself is static HTML and displays. [inferred]

Client-ready summary (108 words)

Hi [Owner] - I looked over plumber-a.example on a phone. The story and the services read well, and the line about educating customers on their options is a real strength. Three quick wins: (1) the phone number at the top isn't tappable, so people can't call with one touch; (2) there's no licence number, insurance or opening hours shown, which is what a homeowner looks for before inviting someone in; (3) the page says both "since 1992" and "started in 2009", and the footer says 2014. I can fix all three in about an hour once you confirm the licence and the dates. Want me to do that?


Self-check against the skill's quality bar

  • Every finding has a quote or measured value: yes.
  • A finding about contacting the business ranks first: yes.
  • Client summary contains only things the owner can verify by opening the site on a phone: yes (the console error was left out of the summary on purpose).

Get this for any site

This is one of eight skills. Get the free sample (two skills), or the full pack.

We store your email only to follow up about this product. Privacy

Get the full pack - $29